Close

1049: Matthew Durham

Matthew Durham was a member of the Oconee County Council in South Carolina. He was arrested by the State Law Enforcement Division after the county sheriff requested they take the case to avoid the appearance of conflict or favoritism. They investigated and determined that “in September of 2020 Durham caused physical harm or injury to a member of his household by grabbing, pushing and shoving them while two minor children were present…Between March 2020 and August 2021 Durham placed a minor child at unreasonable risk of harm by exposing the minor child to multiple incidents of domestic violence,” from WYFF News.

The governor suspended him from his position until the case was resolved. While waiting for a trial, he reconciled with his wife who told prosecutors she would not testify. They had no choice but drop the case despite the bodily injury and risk to the children. See 50 Reasons Women Don’t Leave Abusive Partners from the National Center on Domestic and Sexual Violence.

He was reinstated and welcomed as a conquering hero, the local press said he was cleared which is not the same as declining to prosecute, and to show them all how much they think of him, the council elected him county chair. People gave salutatory speeches while alleging the legal system was weaponized against him.

SLED Press Release announcing charges which has been removed the from SLED press release archive.
Durham cleared - OCONEE COUNTY Reinstated by - Journal, The (Seneca, SC) - March 31, 2023 - page A1
March 31, 2023 | Journal, The (Seneca, SC) | RILEY MORNINGSTAR; THE JOURNAL | Page A1
WALHALLA - The South Carolina Attorney General's Office has declined to prosecute its case against Matthew
Durham, clearing the way for his return to Oconee County Council after what he called a "challenging and
emotional journey." Durham said in a statement after the news he was innocent and looked forward to
"getting back to work."
"This has been a challenging and emotional journey for my family and for myself, but we have emerged
stronger and more resilient. This experience has taught us the importance of standing firm in one's faith,
even in the face of adversity," he said. "I'm grateful for the people of Oconee County and the patience,
compassion and support you've shown my family. The letters, notes and messages of encouragement from
many people that we know and do not know has been humbling and a great blessing. Most of all, I'm grateful
for your prayers.
"Representing the people of District 2 is one of the greatest honors of my life, and I look forward to
continuing to serve the people of Oconee County."
Durham's charges of second-degree domestic violence and unlawful neglect of a child were recorded as
"nolle prosequi indicted" on the online state court index. That means prosecutors have decided not to move
forward with the case and the two indictments are no longer valid. Durham was originally scheduled to be
tried in April on charges of second-degree domestic violence and unlawful neglect of a child filed last May by
the S.C. Law Enforcement Division. The court date was publicly scrapped from the docket earlier this week. A
spokesman with the state prosecutor's office would not comment on the case when asked Thursday morning
why it was no longer being prosecuted.
DURHAM RETURNS TO COUNTY COUNCIL SEAT Hours after he was indicted by a grand jury last May, Durham
was suspended from serving on council by South Carolina Gov. Henry McMaster. McMaster's order ruled that
Durham would be suspended until he was formally acquitted or convicted of the charges. The governor's
office responded to The Journal on Thursday afternoon with an executive order rescinding the suspension
and reinstating Durham "effective immediately."
That now means the body will be whole again at the next council meeting scheduled for April 18 and will
almost certainly elect a new chairman after a continued stalemate started earlier this year. Councilman John
Elliott has served as interim chairman. Since his term began in 2021, Durham has represented himself as a
staunch conservative voice for his district, which includes Mountain Rest, Walhalla and West Union.
He now finds himself in a majority bloc for the first time in his tenure with allies in Councilmen Glenn Hart
and Don Mize, just in time to craft a new budget ahead of the new fiscal year that starts July 1. A preliminary
budget presented earlier this month by county administrator Amanda Brock totaled $67 million and included
an increase in police pay and a new step and scale pay matrix - which would total almost 10 percent more in
expenditures than the current operating budget. morningstar@upstatetoday.com | (864) 973-6685
Copyright 2023, © The Journal/Oconee Publishing, Seneca, SC. All Rights Reserved.
'You definitely deserve this' - OCONEE Durham - Journal, The (Seneca, SC) - April 19, 2023 - page A1
April 19, 2023 | Journal, The (Seneca, SC) | RILEY MORNINGSTAR; THE JOURNAL | Page A1
WALHALLA - The return and subsequent installation of Matthew Durham as the new chairman of the Oconee
County Council was met with applause throughout chambers Tuesday night.
In his first meeting night back on the job, Durham was backed by Councilmen Glenn Hart and Don Mize in a
3-2 vote to be chair.
The return to council for Durham comes after two criminal charges filed last May by the S.C. Law
Enforcement Division of second-degree domestic violence and unlawful neglect of a child were ultimately
expunged in March after the state Attorney General's office elected not prosecute the case.
Though he was voted in to be chair, Durham wasn't the first nomination for the position. Councilman Julian
Davis spoke swiftly to nominate John Elliott and was followed by Hart nominating Durham. The vote for Elliott
failed 2-3, while Durham nominated Mize for vice chair and Hart to be chair pro tem in 3-2 votes. Davis and
Elliott never put up nominations for the other two seats.
Several people in county chambers clapped for Durham as he moved to the center chair.
PU BLIC COM ENTS Perry Smith, a close friend of Durham, opened public comments telling Durham, "You
definitely deserve this."
"Matthew, I just want to say it's great to see you back. You and your family have been put through something
no one else should ever be put through," Smith said. "I feel like the state has weaponized the legal system
against you. It's something a lot of people - some people even in this room - were happy to see this happen to
you.
"I think it's disgusting.
You stood tall, you stood firm in your belief. You didn't back down. I'm humbled to know you because you are
a strong man."
A few of Durham's friends, including former Oconee Republican Party chairman David McMahan, were seated
in the gallery.
McMahan congratulated the three councilmen in their new positions.
"Mr. Durham, it sure is good to see you back and I'm glad to see some conservative values headed back in
Oconee County," he said.
DURHAM EMOTIONAL IN LENGTHY STATEMENT Durham said - at times choking up - in an almost 9-minute
statement, he did send messages to another woman who was not his wife, but never met her without his wife
being present. The law enforcement investigation into Durham started after his wife, Kate Durham, made a
social media post showing bruises on her arm and alleging her husband had been unfaithful in August 2021.
He admitted he was "weak," but that God was "strong." Durham went on to say out how the couple went to
divorce court and reconciled two months later, saying a "thorough" state Department of Social Services
investigation into abuse of his children turned out to be unfounded. Durham said the family turned to God to
save the family and home and he was wrongly arrested nine months later. He said SLED and the attorney
general's office coordinated his arrest to where he was denied due process to a probable cause hearing in
securing an indictment in less than three days, thus removing him from council. Durham closed saying he was
innocent of the crimes and thanked those who stood by him.
"I learned I have true friends - friends that will stand with me through the toughest of times," Durham said.
"The people of this community have been kind and compassionate toward myself and my family." ECONOMIC
DEVELOPMENT PROJECT TURNED DOWN The entirety of council united against awarding economic incentives
to Waterview Investment and Ravenel Development to build 400 student housing units along U.S. Highway
123 around Paws Diner. The project would have been awarded a $3 million incentive and a fee-in-lieu-of-tax
agreement for investing $140 million in the county. The company would have received a $3 million incentive
from the county if it invested $4.2 million in sewer infrastructure upgrades.
Elliott said he was against "any further expansion of student housing in Oconee County." "Student housing is
not economic development, it's economic disaster," he said. "Student housing puts strains on our sheriff's
department, our fire services and other emergency services."
Davis voted against the project, but didn't condemn student housing at-large.
"To consider any kind of student housing a bad investment or a wear on this county does not really open up
our eyes to the future growth of this area," he said. "Am I for this infrastructure agreement here, per se? No,
but my issue with that is it's not a bad thing to have student housing because it's also family housing, as well."
Durham said housing shouldn't be subsidized with taxpayer money.
"They're coming whether we give them money or not," he said.
Editor's note: The Journal will have extensive coverage of Tuesday's Oconee County Council meeting
throughout the week, including comments made by former councilman Wayne McCall that he was threatened
by special interest groups and a new budgeting method proposed by Councilman Matthew Durham.
morningstar@upstatetoday.com (864) 973-6685
Copyright 2023, © The Journal/Oconee Publishing, Seneca, SC. All Rights Reserved.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *